Remember that feeling when you finally found the perfect shade of crayon eyeliner? It glides on smoothly, stays put all day, and makes your eyes pop! But for many of us, finding that dream eyeliner can feel like a treasure hunt. So many brands, so many colors, and so many promises! It’s easy to get overwhelmed, right? You want an eyeliner that’s easy to use, doesn’t smudge, and looks amazing, but sometimes you end up with one that’s too hard, too waxy, or just fades away too quickly.
Choosing the right crayon eyeliner pencil shouldn’t be a chore. It should be an exciting part of creating your unique look! That’s why we’re diving deep into the world of crayon eyeliners today. We’ll explore what makes a great one, what to look for, and how to avoid those common frustrations.
By the end of this post, you’ll feel confident picking out your next crayon eyeliner. You’ll learn tips for finding the best formulas and colors for your needs, so you can create stunning eye looks without the guesswork. Get ready to discover your new go-to eyeliner!
Our Top 5 Crayon Eyeliner Pencil Recommendations at a Glance
| Image | Product | Rating | Links |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil | 8.8/10 | Check Price |
 |
Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner | 8.7/10 | Check Price |
 |
e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner | 9.1/10 | Check Price |
 |
L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner | 9.3/10 | Check Price |
 |
Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner | 9.3/10 | Check Price |
Top 5 Crayon Eyeliner Pencil Detailed Reviews
1. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil
Rating: 8.6/10
The NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil in Black Bean is a super handy makeup tool. It’s like having three products in one! You can use it as a creamy eyeshadow, a bold eyeliner, or even a bright highlighter. This pencil makes it easy to add a pop of intense color anywhere you want. It’s great for your waterline, the inner corners of your eyes, or all over your lid.
What We Like:
- It’s a triple threat: eyeshadow, eyeliner, and highlighter all in one stick.
- The creamy formula glides on smoothly without pulling or tugging.
- It stays put and doesn’t fade throughout the day.
- You can use it on your waterlines, inner corners, and lids for a vibrant look.
- NYX Professional Makeup is a cruelty-free brand, certified by PETA.
- It comes in many beautiful colors and finishes, from matte to shimmery.
What Could Be Improved:
- While versatile, some users might find it takes a bit of practice to get a super sharp eyeliner wing.
- The jumbo size, while great for lids, might be a little big for very precise inner-corner highlighting for some.
This NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil is a fantastic, easy-to-use product that lets you create many different eye looks. It’s a must-have for anyone looking to add some fun and color to their makeup routine.
2. Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner
Rating: 9.4/10
Tired of eyeliner that smudges or fades before your day is done? The Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner promises to solve that problem. This eyeliner comes in a deep Black Brown shade and is designed to stay put for hours. It even has a sharpener built right in!
What We Like:
- The color stays rich and looks fresh all day.
- It’s waterproof, transfer-proof, and won’t smudge or fade.
- It lasts for up to 24 hours, so you don’t have to worry about touch-ups.
- It glides on smoothly for easy application.
- You can create subtle or dramatic eye looks.
- The built-in sharpener keeps the tip perfect.
- It includes a smudger for blending.
- It comes in 12 different matte and shimmer colors.
- It’s safe for your waterline and comfortable to wear.
What Could Be Improved:
- The “0.01 oz” size might seem small to some.
- While it’s smudge-proof once set, some users might find it smudges slightly during initial application if not careful.
This eyeliner offers impressive staying power and versatility for creating different eye looks. It’s a reliable choice for makeup that lasts.
3. e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner
Rating: 9.2/10
Get ready to create some amazing eye looks with the e.l.f. Smoky Kohl Eyeliner in Black Velvet! This eyeliner pencil is super smooth and perfect for drawing sharp lines or making a dramatic smoky eye. It’s made with good stuff and is kind to animals, so you can feel good about using it.
What We Like:
- It glides on so smoothly, making it easy to apply.
- You can easily blend and smudge it to get that perfect smoky look.
- The color is really bold and stays put for a long time.
- It’s vegan and cruelty-free, which is awesome!
- The “Black Velvet” shade is a deep, intense black.
What Could Be Improved:
- For some, the pencil might need sharpening more often than a twist-up liner.
- While it’s long-lasting, a truly waterproof formula might be preferred by some for extreme conditions.
This eyeliner is a fantastic tool for anyone wanting to add some drama and definition to their eyes. It makes achieving a bold, smoky look simple and accessible.
4. L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner
Rating: 8.6/10
Get ready for eyes that truly pop with the L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner in Black. This eyeliner is designed to give you a dramatic and captivating look. Its special dark kajal formula packs a punch with intense black color. You’ll love how smoothly it glides on, making it easy to create stunning definition for your eyes. Whether you’re going for a subtle everyday look or a bold cat eye, this liner is your new go-to.
What We Like:
- Richly intense black color for dramatic definition.
- Glides on effortlessly for a smooth application.
- Versatile for everyday looks or bold cat eyes.
- Pairs perfectly with Voluminous Original Volume Building Mascara for fuller lashes.
- Helps you create the eye look you desire.
What Could Be Improved:
- The description doesn’t mention if it’s waterproof or smudge-proof, which is a common feature many look for in eyeliner.
- While it promises intensity, the exact longevity of the “smoldering” effect throughout the day isn’t detailed.
This L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner is a fantastic tool for enhancing your eyes. It makes achieving a dramatic look simple and effective.
5. Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner
Rating: 8.7/10
Get ready for stunning eyes that last! The Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner in 201 Black is your new go-to for amazing eye makeup. This eyeliner promises rich color that stays put all day, without smudging or fading. It’s perfect for creating any look you can imagine, from a soft, subtle line to a bold, dramatic statement.
What We Like:
- The color stays vibrant and looks freshly applied for a long time.
- It’s completely waterproof, smudge-proof, and won’t transfer.
- You can wear it for up to 24 hours, so it lasts through your whole day and night.
- It glides on super smoothly, making it easy to draw precise lines.
- It comes with a built-in sharpener to keep the tip perfectly pointed.
- There’s also a smudger included to help you blend and create different effects.
- You can use it on your waterline safely because it’s tested by eye doctors.
- It feels comfortable to wear all day.
- It comes in 12 different shades with both matte and shimmery finishes.
What Could Be Improved:
- Sometimes the built-in sharpener can be a little messy.
- The smudger could be a bit softer for easier blending.
This eyeliner is a fantastic choice for anyone who wants long-lasting, beautiful eye makeup. It delivers on its promises and is comfortable enough to wear every day.
The Ultimate Buying Guide: Your Go-To Crayon Eyeliner Pencil
Ready to add some drama or definition to your eyes? Crayon eyeliner pencils are your fun, easy-to-use secret weapon! They’re like a super-powered pencil for your eyelids. This guide will help you pick the perfect one.
What to Look For: Key Features
When you’re shopping for a crayon eyeliner pencil, keep these important features in mind:
- Pigmentation: This means how strong and bright the color is. A good crayon eyeliner pencil shows up well with just one swipe. You want a color that pops!
- Smoothness: The pencil should glide easily across your eyelid. No tugging or skipping! A smooth formula makes application a breeze.
- Longevity: You want your eyeliner to stay put all day. Look for pencils that are smudge-proof and waterproof. This means no messy raccoon eyes!
- Ease of Sharpening: Some pencils are retractable, meaning you twist them up. Others need a sharpener. If it needs a sharpener, make sure it sharpens nicely without breaking.
- Color Variety: Do you want classic black, deep brown, or something bold and colorful? Many brands offer a rainbow of shades. Pick what suits your style!
Important Materials
Most crayon eyeliners are made with a mix of waxes, oils, and pigments.
- Waxes (like Carnauba or Beeswax): These give the pencil its structure and help it glide.
- Oils (like Jojoba or Mineral Oil): These make the formula creamy and prevent it from drying out your eyelid.
- Pigments: These are the colorants that give the eyeliner its shade.
Sometimes, extra ingredients are added for benefits like staying power or a smoother feel.
Factors That Improve or Reduce Quality
What makes a crayon eyeliner pencil great?
- Good Quality Ingredients: When brands use better waxes and oils, the pencil feels smoother and lasts longer. High-quality pigments make the color richer.
- Formulation: A well-balanced formula prevents the pencil from being too hard (hard to apply) or too soft (smudges easily).
- Packaging: A sturdy pencil that doesn’t break easily is a plus. If it’s retractable, the twist mechanism should work smoothly.
What can make it not so great?
- Cheap Ingredients: These can make the pencil rough to apply and cause irritation.
- Poor Formulation: A pencil that is too dry will skip and tug. One that is too waxy will smudge easily.
- Brittle Lead: The tip can break off easily during application or sharpening.
User Experience and Use Cases
Using a crayon eyeliner pencil is super simple!
- Beginner Friendly: They are great for people just starting with eyeliner. You can draw a thin line, a thicker line, or even smudge it out for a smoky look.
- Everyday Wear: A simple line along your upper lash line can make your eyes look more awake and defined. Brown shades are great for a softer, natural look.
- Bold Looks: Black eyeliner is perfect for creating dramatic cat-eye looks. Colorful eyeliners can add a fun pop to your makeup.
- Smoky Eyes: You can apply the crayon liner and then use a brush or your finger to smudge it out for a beautiful smoky effect.
- Tightlining: This is when you carefully apply liner to your upper waterline (the inside edge of your upper lid). It makes your lashes look fuller.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: What is the main difference between a crayon eyeliner and a liquid eyeliner?
A: Crayon eyeliners are pencil-shaped and usually softer, making them easier to blend and smudge. Liquid eyeliners come in a pot or pen and create sharper, more precise lines.
Q: Can I use a crayon eyeliner on my waterline?
A: Yes, many crayon eyeliners are safe for the waterline. Look for ones labeled as “waterproof” or “smudge-proof” for the best staying power.
Q: How do I prevent my crayon eyeliner from smudging?
A: First, make sure the eyeliner is truly smudge-proof. You can also apply a thin layer of eyeshadow in a similar color over the liner to set it. Sometimes, using an eyeshadow primer beforehand helps too.
Q: How do I sharpen a crayon eyeliner pencil?
A: Use a sharpener specifically designed for makeup pencils. If the lead is very soft, you might want to chill the pencil in the refrigerator for a few minutes before sharpening to prevent it from breaking.
Q: What are the best crayon eyeliner colors for beginners?
A: Black and dark brown are excellent choices for beginners. They are versatile and help you practice creating clean lines.
Q: Can crayon eyeliner be used for a winged eyeliner look?
A: Absolutely! While liquid liner is often used for super sharp wings, a well-formulated crayon eyeliner can create a beautiful, softer wing. Smudging it slightly can give a more diffused effect.
Q: How long should a crayon eyeliner pencil last?
A: This varies depending on how often you use it and how much you sharpen it. Generally, a pencil can last several months with regular use.
Q: Are crayon eyeliners good for sensitive eyes?
A: Look for hypoallergenic formulas and those free from common irritants like fragrance. Patch testing on your hand before applying to your eyes is always a good idea.
Q: Can I use crayon eyeliner to create a smoky eye?
A: Yes! Crayon eyeliners are perfect for smoky eyes because their creamy texture makes them easy to blend out before they set.
Q: What does “retractable” mean for an eyeliner pencil?
A: Retractable means the eyeliner can be twisted up to reveal more product and twisted back down to protect the tip. You don’t need a sharpener for these.
In conclusion, every product has unique features and benefits. We hope this review helps you decide if it meets your needs. An informed choice ensures the best experience.
If you have any questions or feedback, please share them in the comments. Your input helps everyone. Thank you for reading.