Top 5 Drywall Screws: Essential Review Guide Now

Ever wonder what holds your beautiful walls together? It’s often a tiny but mighty piece of hardware: the drywall screw. These small fasteners are the unsung heroes of construction and home repair. But choosing the wrong one can lead to big headaches down the line, like screws popping out or rusting through your perfect paint job.

Selecting the correct drywall screw feels complicated. Should you use coarse or fine thread? Black phosphate or something else? These small details make a huge difference in how strong and lasting your drywall installation becomes. Getting it wrong wastes time, money, and can ruin the finish of your project.

This post cuts through the confusion. We will break down what you need to know about drywall screws simply and clearly. You will learn to identify the right screw for wood studs versus metal framing. By the end, you will confidently pick the perfect fastener every time.

Top Drywall Screws Recommendations

No. 1
JEGONFRI High Hardness Drywall Screws Assortment Kit, 166 pcs, Coarse Thread, Phillips Drive, Black Wood Screws, Screws Assortment, Screws Set, 6 Sizes (3”,2”,1-1/2”,1-1/4”,1”,3/4”)
  • SUPERIOR SCREW: Composed of high strength 1022A carbon steel. The heat-treated thread is very clear and the sharp tip can penetrate wood quickly. Finished in rustproof black phosphate coating, can withstand prolonged salt spray testing.
  • VARIOUS SIZES: A kit of drywall screws in 6 commonly used sizes( #8 x 3 in, #6 x 2 in, #6 x 1-1/2 in, #6 x 1-1/4 in, #6 x 1 in, #6 x 3/4 in ), a total of 166 for diverse projects.
  • WIDE USE: The screw set can be used for plank, gypsum board, composite board, soft metal, plastic. Easy to install with screwdriver or electric drill.
  • CONVENIENT CASE: Place in different grids according to the size, which is efficient to find the desired size. Polypropylene box of excellent material can be reused as a storage box.
  • WARM PROMPT: It is recommend for best result to drill holes in advance. And ensure secure holding, not easy to slide when using.
No. 2
JEGONFRI 210pcs #6 × 1-1/4 inch High Hardness Drywall Screws, Black, Coarse Thread, Phillips Drive, Bugle Head, Black Wood Screws, Wood and More (1-1/4 in, 210)
  • Include: #6 x 1-1/4” drywall screw, 210 pieces per pack.
  • Material: Made of high hardness 1022A carbon steel to provide strong durability and finished in rustproof black phosphate coating.
  • Workmanship: Adopting heat treated and high-precise cutting technology, the screw thread is very sharp and clear.
  • Application: Apply to use with various projects, mainly connect between material like plank, gypsum board, composite board, soft metal, plastic. And easy to install with only a few simple tools. Ensure secure holding, not easy to slide when using.
  • Warm Prompt: It is recommended to cover the lid after use to slow down oxidation.
No. 3
245 Pcs M3.5 Self-Tapping Screw Assortment Kit - Black Flat Head Wood & Drywall Screws (16-50mm), 7 Lengths for Furniture, Cabinets & DIY | with Storage Case
  • 【Complete 245-Pc M3.5 Screw Solution】 This versatile kit provides 245 self-tapping screws across 7 essential lengths (16mm to 50mm). With a consistent M3.5 diameter, it’s the perfect organized inventory for a wide range of fine woodworking, assembly, and repair tasks
  • 【Self-Driving Design for Effortless Installation】 Features a sharp point and deep, clean threads that tap their own mating thread as you drive them. This eliminates the need for pre-drilling in most wood and drywall applications, saving you significant time and effort
  • 【Durable Carbon Steel with Rust-Resistant Finish】 Constructed from hardened carbon steel with a protective black plating. These screws offer high strength to resist bending or snapping, along with corrosion resistance for long-lasting, reliable holds in indoor projects
  • 【Flush-Fit Flat Head & Wide Compatibility】 The flat countersunk head design allows screws to sit flush or below the material surface for a clean, finished look. Excellent for securing wood to wood, attaching drywall to studs, fastening thin metal brackets, and general DIY crafts
  • 【Organized for Instant Access & Portability】 All screws are pre-sorted by length in a durable, compartmentalized plastic case. Find the exact 25mm or 40mm screw you need in seconds. The portable case keeps your workspace tidy and your screws ready for any project at home or in the workshop
No. 4
KURUI Drywall Anchors and Screws Assortment Kit 270PCS, 135 Plastic Dry Wall Expansion Anchors and 135 Philips Flat Head Wood Screws, 5 Sizes Wall Hanging Kit for Art Decor, Replaces Picture Nails
  • FIVE ESSENTIAL SIZES FOR MULTIPLE PROJECTS: This dry wall anchors and screws kit comes with five of the most widely used sizes: #6 1", #7 1", #6 1-1/5", #8 1-3/5", and #8 2-2/5". It works for all types of hanging installation needs, and pairs great with a drywall repair kit, whether you’re mounting shelves, fixing curtain rods, or hanging bathroom living room wall decor.
  • PREMIUM MATERIALS FOR SUPERIOR DURABILITY: Our plastic wall anchors are crafted from a high-performance nylon and PE compound, providing enhanced strength, wear resistance, and long-lasting reliability. The ribbed design ensures a tight grip inside the wall, preventing slipping or loosening over time. The galvanized Phillips screws made of high-carbon steel offer outstanding hardness and resistance to rust and corrosion, making them ideal for both indoor and outdoor applications.
  • CLEARLY ASSORTED FOR EASY SELECTION – the drywall anchors and wood screws assortment kit come with a well-built clear plastic organizer box, which keeps screws and plastic anchors of each sizes neatly and clearly, allowing you to access the one you need easily by a glance. The compact organizer saves you bunch of time searching and takes up no space in your house.
  • WIDE COMPATIBILITY WITH DIFFERENT WALL TYPES: Engineered for versatility, these plastic wall anchors can be used on drywall, concrete, brick, wood and more. Whether you need to mount picture frames, towel racks, floating shelves, light fixtures, or other household items, this kit ensures a secure and reliable hold. Thanks to its high-strength materials and ribbed design, you can use it for both light and medium-weight applications without worrying.
  • WHAT YOU GET – You will receive 135 plastic drywall anchors, 135 galvanized Philips wood screws and 1 attractive clear plastic organizer boxes. Each product purchased from us comes with a one-month free replacement and refund service, making your shopping experience hassle-free. If you have any question of you unhappy with anything, please don’t hesitate to contact us!
No. 5
KURUI Drywall Screws Assortment Kit, #6 Black Wood Screws for Sheetrock,165pcs Picture Hanging Kit for Frame Painting Art Photo, Phillips Coarse Dry Wall Screw 4 Sizes 1",1-1/4",1-5/8",2"
  • MATERIAL OF THE HIGHEST GRADE - The black wood screws assortment kits are constructed of brand new material of the highest possible quality, which has an exceptional degree of brittleness. The surface has been galvanised and phosphated, which provides exceptional protection against rust and a fast and efficient self-tapping speed.
  • WIDE RANGE OF SIZE OPTIONS - This Drywall Screws Assortment Kit is available in a wide range of different size options, including 1", 1-1/4", 1-5/8", and 2". A storage container has one of each size neatly organised inside of it.
  • CLEAR AND WELL-ORGANIZED CONTAINER INCLUDED - The Black Sheetrock Screws assorted kit comes with a well-built clear storage container that keeps the Sheetrock Screws clearly arranged so that you can get what you need at a glance when you're using it, saving you a lot of time searching and matching.
  • WIDE VARIETY OF USES - The black wood screw set's assortment of sizes makes it useful for a variety of tasks, including those using plasterboard and wood. Because of its dependable quality and long-lasting nature, you can make use of it with full trust.
  • WHAT YOU GET - You will receive a great clear sorting storage box in addition to the following: 60 pieces #6*1", 50 pieces #6*1-1/4", 30 pieces #6*1-5/8", 25 pieces #6*2", and a nice clear sorting storage box. If you have any question regarding this drywall screws assortment kit, please feel free to turn to us.
No. 6
Self Drilling Drywall Anchors with Screws Kit 100Pcs- 50 Sheetrock Anchors 50 Zinc Expansion Screws New Upgraded Zinc Plated Steel No Drill or Holes in Wall,for Wall Hanging,Cabinets,Holds Up to 80LB
  • Premium Corrosion-Resistant Construction:Carbon steel anchors with zinc shielding combat rust and wear. Reinforced design engages fully when tightened, delivering rock-solid stability in hollow walls.Load capacity: approximately 80 pounds
  • Damage-Free Direct Installation:Self-penetrating screws mount instantly—no pilot holes. Hammer anchors flush, insert fasteners, tighten. Zero visible wall damage upon removal.
  • Full-Surface Grip Technology:Engineered threads maximize weight distribution. Anchors engage completely to hold heavy objects with steadfast security.
  • Universal Hollow Material Solution: Drywall anchors are suitable for drywall, gypsum board, and porous brick. Easily mount TVs, shelves, curtains, artwork, lamps, pendants, indoor planters, hanging planters, and picture hanging kit.
  • Complete Reusable Hardware Kit:Multi-size anchors and screws included. Remove objects while leaving anchors embedded—adjust and reuse endlessly.
No. 7
Grip-Rite 1CDWS1 #6 X 1" Phillips Bugle Head Coarse Thread Sharp Point Drywall Screw, 1lb Box
  • COARSE THREADS: For attaching drywall to wood studs
  • PHOSPHATE COATED: For improved paint and mud adhesion
  • BUGLE HEAD: #2 Philips Bugle head for easy countersinking into drywall
No. 8
VGBUY 170pcs #6 × 1-1/2 inch Drywall Screws, Black Wood Screws, Coarse Thread Sheetrock Screws, Phillips Head Drive, High Hardness Black Screws for Drywall, Sheetrock, Wood
  • High Hardness Drywall Screws: VGBUY black drywall screws made of high-quality crabon steel, strong and durable, not easy to deform or snap off. Surface treated with black oxide, which has higher corrosion resistance and anti-rust effect.
  • Well Made Wood Screws: These black wood screws have a sharp tip,coarse thread,bugle head and a cross-drive flat. They are essential in construction and renovation projects due to their ability to provide a strong, secure attachment while minimizing damage to the drywall.
  • Package Includes: You will get 170pcs #6 × 1-1/2 inch sheetrock screws and a nice clear sorting storage box. They are ideal for attaching drywall or gypsum to wood studs and general interior wood applications.
  • Superior Process: Coarse thread design effectively grab wood stubs, and sharp point can help pierce through drywall to achieve fixed effect. The tapered bugle head that countersinks easily without damaging the drywall paper cover. Phillips drive head helps ensure that these black screws are driven straight with strong holding power.
  • Widely Applications: These dry wall screws are excellent for drywall, wall board, plaster board, sheet rock, gypsum board, and other materials. Designed specifically for securing drywall or gypsum board to wood or metal studs. Can be ideal for your home, office, or workplace.

Choosing the Right Drywall Screws: A Buyer’s Guide

Drywall screws are essential tools for any building project. They hold drywall sheets firmly to wood or metal studs. Picking the right screw makes your job faster and your walls stronger. This guide helps you choose the perfect fasteners for your needs.

Key Features to Look For

When shopping for drywall screws, several features matter a lot.

  • Head Type: Most drywall screws have a bugle head. This cone-like shape sinks slightly below the paper surface without tearing it. This allows for easy mudding later.
  • Thread Type: Screws come with coarse or fine threads. Coarse threads work best for attaching drywall to wooden studs. Fine threads are ideal for securing drywall to metal studs.
  • Length: Screw length depends on your drywall thickness. For standard 1/2-inch drywall attached to wood, 1-1/4 inch screws are common. Always ensure the screw penetrates the wood stud by at least 5/8 inch for a secure hold.
  • Drive Type: Phillips heads are standard. Square drive (Robertson) or Torx drives offer better grip and reduce “cam-out” (when the driver slips out of the screw head).
Important Materials and Coatings

The material of the screw affects its strength and how long it lasts.

Most drywall screws are made of hardened steel. This makes them strong enough to penetrate the gypsum core and the stud material. Quality screws undergo a heat-treating process. This process increases their hardness significantly.

Coatings are very important, especially in damp areas. Standard drywall screws have a black phosphate coating. This coating offers minimal rust protection. If you work in a basement or bathroom, look for screws with a corrosion-resistant coating, like zinc plating. These resist moisture much better.

Factors That Improve or Reduce Quality

Good screws perform well; bad ones cause frustration.

Quality Boosters:

  • Sharp Point: A sharp point pierces the drywall paper easily. This saves time and prevents the screw tip from “walking” away from your target spot.
  • Consistent Hardness: A uniformly hardened screw resists snapping under tension. Cheap screws often snap when driven too hard.
  • Accurate Threading: Well-cut threads grip the stud tightly. This prevents the screw from backing out over time.

Quality Reducers:

  • Soft Metal: Screws made from soft, untreated steel bend easily. They also strip out at the head quickly.
  • Poor Coating: Thin or patchy coatings fail quickly, leading to rust stains bleeding through your finished paint job.
  • Dull Tip: A dull tip forces you to push harder, often resulting in a damaged screw head or torn drywall paper.
User Experience and Use Cases

Using the correct screw improves the user experience greatly. When screws drive easily and sit flush, finishing the wall goes smoothly.

Wood Framing: Use coarse-threaded screws. They bite into wood fibers quickly and hold securely for decades.

Metal Framing: You must use fine-threaded screws for metal studs. These screws have sharper threads that cut into the thin metal without stripping the threads away.

Outdoor/Wet Areas: Never use standard black phosphate screws outside or on ceilings near plumbing. Always choose corrosion-resistant options for these damp environments to prevent structural failure and ugly rust spots.


10 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About Drywall Screws

Q: What is the difference between a drywall screw and a wood screw?

A: Drywall screws have a bugle head designed to recess without tearing the paper. They are also often thinner than standard wood screws.

Q: Why do my drywall screws keep snapping?

A: Screws usually snap because the metal is too brittle (not properly heat-treated) or because you are driving them too fast into dense material.

Q: Can I use coarse thread screws on metal studs?

A: No. You must use fine-thread screws on metal studs. Coarse threads are for wood framing only.

Q: What is the standard length for hanging 1/2-inch drywall?

A: The most common length for 1/2-inch drywall on wood studs is 1-1/4 inches.

Q: What does the black color mean on drywall screws?

A: The black color comes from the standard black phosphate coating. It offers very basic protection against rust but is not waterproof.

Q: Should I use a special bit for drywall screws?

A: A standard Phillips #2 bit works for most. However, a square (Robertson) or Torx bit provides better grip and prevents the bit from slipping out of the head.

Q: Do I need to countersink the screw heads?

A: Yes, you must countersink them slightly below the surface of the paper. This allows you to cover the screw head with joint compound (mud).

Q: What happens if the screw head tears the paper?

A: Tearing the paper weakens the bond. The screw might pull out later, leading to a visible dimple or crack on the finished wall surface.

Q: Are galvanized screws better than phosphate-coated screws?

A: Galvanized (zinc-coated) screws offer much better corrosion resistance than simple phosphate coatings, making them better for humid areas.

Q: Can I use drywall screws to attach wood trim?

A: While possible, it is not recommended. Drywall screws are brittle. Use proper wood trim screws for better holding power and less chance of snapping.