How do you determine fantasy football draft order? The most common and fair methods involve a lottery system or a schedule based on the previous year’s standings, often utilizing a draft order generator.
Getting your fantasy football draft order right is crucial for a fair and fun league. It’s the bedrock upon which your season is built. A flawed system can lead to resentment and a less competitive environment. This guide dives deep into various methods for determining draft order, ensuring your league starts on the right foot. We’ll cover everything from traditional approaches to more innovative solutions, helping you craft the perfect system for your league.
Image Source: images.squarespace-cdn.com
The Foundation of Fairness: Why Draft Order Matters
The draft order dictates which manager gets to pick first, second, third, and so on. This is incredibly important in fantasy sports because the early draft picks often have access to the top-tier players. Imagine a league where the manager who finished last last year consistently gets the first pick. This creates an imbalance that can discourage participation and make the season feel predetermined. A fair draft order promotes competition and ensures that every manager feels they have a legitimate chance to win. It’s not just about who picks where; it’s about the perceived integrity of the league itself.
Common Fantasy Football Draft Methods
There are several popular ways leagues decide who picks when. Each has its pros and cons, and the best choice often depends on your league’s personality and priorities.
Previous Season’s Standings (Reverse Order)
This is arguably the most common and widely accepted method. The team that finished last in the previous season gets the first overall pick. The second-to-last place team gets the second pick, and so on, until the league champion gets the last pick.
How it Works:
- Identify Final Standings: The league commissioner or a designated person confirms the final standings from the previous season, including any tie-breaking rules that were used.
- Assign Picks:
- Last Place: Pick 1.01, 2.01, 3.01, etc.
- Second to Last Place: Pick 1.02, 2.02, 3.02, etc.
- …
- Champion: Pick 1.12, 2.12, 3.12, etc. (for a 12-team league).
Advantages:
- Rewards Poor Performance: This system directly incentivizes teams to perform poorly to get better draft picks. While this sounds counterintuitive, it’s a common fantasy trope – “tanking” for a better pick.
- Simple and Understandable: Most fantasy players are familiar with this method, making it easy to implement and explain.
- Promotes Parity: Over time, this system can help to level the playing field, as consistently bad teams get opportunities to draft top talent.
Disadvantages:
- Can Discourage Trying: If a team is mathematically eliminated from playoff contention early, they might have no incentive to try and win their remaining games, as losing could secure them a better draft pick.
- Requires Previous Season Data: This method is not suitable for new leagues.
The Fantasy Football Draft Lottery
A draft lottery is a fun and engaging way to determine draft order, especially for new leagues or leagues looking for a fresh start. It removes the direct link to past performance and adds an element of chance.
How it Works:
- Assign Numbers: Each manager is assigned a unique number corresponding to their draft position (e.g., Manager A gets #1, Manager B gets #2, etc.).
- Conduct the Lottery: There are several ways to run a lottery:
- Physical Drawing: Write each number on a piece of paper, put them in a hat, and draw them out one by one. The order of drawing determines the draft order.
- Online Draft Order Generator: Many fantasy sports platforms and websites offer a “draft lottery” or “random draft selection” feature. You input the managers, and the system randomly assigns the draft order.
- Sports-Themed Lottery: Assign managers to real-life NFL games or players. The outcome of those games or the performance of those players can determine the draft order. For example, the manager whose assigned NFL team scores the fewest points in Week 1 gets the first pick.
Advantages:
- Pure Randomness: Ensures everyone has an equal chance, regardless of past performance.
- Exciting Event: The lottery itself can be a pre-draft event, building anticipation.
- Good for New Leagues: It’s the perfect solution when there’s no previous season data.
Disadvantages:
- No Skill or Strategy Involved: It’s entirely up to luck. A great manager could end up with the last pick.
- Potential for Frustration: Managers who get a late pick purely by chance might feel less invested.
Custom Draft Rules and Tie-Breaking Procedures
Leagues can get creative with their draft order. This often involves incorporating unique elements or using specific tie-breaking rules to ensure fairness.
Examples of Custom Rules:
- Playoff Matchups: If a league uses a playoff system, the draft order for the non-playoff teams can be determined by their regular-season performance. For the playoff teams, their order might be based on how far they advanced, but with a twist. For instance, the team that lost in the championship game gets the first pick, the semi-final losers get the next picks, and the champion gets the last.
- Randomized Within Tiers: Group teams into tiers (e.g., playoff teams, middle-of-the-pack teams, non-playoff teams) and then randomize the draft order within those tiers.
- Tie-Breaker Application: If two teams finish with identical regular-season records, tie-breaking rules are crucial. Common tie-breakers include:
- Head-to-head record between the tied teams.
- Total points scored during the regular season.
- Points scored in head-to-head matchups.
- Coin flip.
- The league’s “draft order generator” often has built-in tie-breaker options.
Advantages:
- Tailored to Your League: Allows for a personalized and engaging experience.
- Can Incorporate Skill: Some custom rules can still reward or penalize performance in specific ways.
Disadvantages:
- Complexity: Can become complicated if too many rules are introduced.
- Requires Clear Documentation: All custom rules must be clearly communicated and agreed upon by all league members before the season starts.
Snake Draft Order Explained
The “snake draft order” is the most common format for traditional fantasy football drafts where managers take turns picking players. It’s designed to somewhat mitigate the disadvantage of having a later pick in the first round.
How the Snake Works:
In a snake draft, the order reverses after each round.
- Round 1: Manager 1 picks first, Manager 2 picks second, …, Manager 12 picks last.
- Round 2: The order reverses. The manager who picked last in Round 1 (Manager 12) now picks first in Round 2. Manager 1 picks last in Round 2.
- Round 3: The order reverses again, returning to the Round 1 order.
- This pattern continues for all rounds of the draft.
Example (10-Team League):
| Round | Pick 1 | Pick 2 | Pick 3 | Pick 4 | Pick 5 | Pick 6 | Pick 7 | Pick 8 | Pick 9 | Pick 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
| 2 | 10 | 9 | 8 | 7 | 6 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
| 3 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
| 4 | 10 | 9 | 8 | 7 | 6 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
Advantages of Snake Draft Order:
- Reduces Extreme Disparity: While getting the #1 pick is still valuable, the snake system means the manager who picks last in Round 1 gets the first pick in Round 2. This helps to balance the draft.
- Strategic Opportunities: Managers with later picks in Round 1 can focus on a different strategy, potentially grabbing two strong players back-to-back at the end of Round 1 and the beginning of Round 2.
Disadvantages of Snake Draft Order:
- Still Has Advantage: The #1 pick is still generally considered the most advantageous position.
- Pacing: Some managers find the back-to-back picks in the middle rounds can be overwhelming.
Auction Draft Order Considerations
Auction drafts operate differently from snake drafts. Instead of picking players in a set order, managers bid on players using a limited budget (e.g., $200). The “draft order” in an auction is actually the nomination order – who gets to nominate the first player for auction.
How Auction Draft Order is Determined:
- Random Selection: Similar to snake drafts, a random draft lottery is the most common method for determining who nominates the first player.
- Previous Standings (Less Common): Some leagues might use previous season standings to determine the nomination order, but this is less prevalent than in snake drafts.
- Commissioner’s Choice: The commissioner might have the discretion to set the initial nomination order.
The Importance of Nomination Order in Auction Drafts:
The order in which players are nominated significantly impacts the auction.
- Early Nominees: The manager who nominates the first player has the advantage of setting the market for top-tier talent. They can nominate a superstar to see how much other managers are willing to spend early.
- Late Nominees: Managers who nominate later might have a better sense of how much money is left in other teams’ budgets, allowing them to make strategic nominations for players they want or players they believe will be undervalued.
Advantages of Auction Drafts:
- More Control: Managers have more control over which players they acquire.
- Levels the Playing Field: Every manager has the same budget, making it a true test of valuation and bidding strategy.
- Every Player is Available: Unlike snake drafts where top players are gone quickly, in an auction, any player can theoretically be acquired if a manager has the budget.
Disadvantages of Auction Drafts:
- Can Be Time-Consuming: Auctions can take longer than snake drafts.
- Requires Budget Management: Managers need to be good at managing their virtual salaries.
- Nomination Strategy is Key: A poor nomination strategy can severely hinder a manager’s team.
Utilizing a Draft Order Generator
A draft order generator is an invaluable tool for any league commissioner. These online tools automate the process of randomizing draft order, saving time and ensuring impartiality.
How to Use a Draft Order Generator:
- Select Your League: Many fantasy football platforms (ESPN, Yahoo, Sleeper, etc.) have built-in draft order generators.
- Input Managers: Enter the names of all league members.
- Choose Method: Select the randomization method (e.g., pure random, lottery based on specific criteria, previous year’s standings).
- Run the Generator: The tool will then produce a draft order.
Key Features to Look For in a Draft Order Generator:
- Multiple Randomization Options: Can it do simple random draws, or does it offer more complex seeded lotteries?
- Tie-Breaking Capabilities: Can it handle situations where multiple teams might theoretically get the same random draw?
- Transparency: Is the process clear and easy to verify?
- Integration: Does it work with your chosen fantasy platform?
Draft Preparation: Ensuring a Smooth Process
Regardless of how you determine your draft order, thorough preparation is key to a successful fantasy football draft.
League Settings Review
Before the draft even begins, ensure all league settings are finalized and clearly communicated. This includes:
- League Size: How many teams are in the league?
- Scoring System: PPR, standard, half-PPR?
- Roster Requirements: How many QBs, RBs, WRs, TEs, Flex, Kickers, Defenses?
- Waiver Wire Rules: FAAB or rolling waivers?
- Playoff Structure: How many teams make the playoffs and when?
- Draft Type: Snake or Auction?
- Draft Date and Time: When is the draft happening?
Crucially, the draft order determination method must be agreed upon and communicated well in advance.
Communicating the Draft Order
Once the draft order is set, make sure every manager knows their position.
- Post it Clearly: Share the draft order in your league’s chat, on the league message board, or via email.
- Explain the Method: Briefly reiterate how the order was determined to reinforce fairness.
- Confirm Understanding: Ask managers to acknowledge they’ve seen and understood their draft position.
Pre-Draft Research
Even with the best draft order, a manager’s success hinges on their preparation.
- Player Rankings: Create or consult expert player rankings.
- Mock Drafts: Participate in mock drafts to get a feel for player availability and draft trends.
- Team Needs: Consider the strengths and weaknesses of your own team and your opponents.
- Sleepers and Busts: Identify players who might outperform or underperform their draft position.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: What is the most common fantasy football draft order method?
A1: The most common method is to use the reverse order of the previous season’s standings. The team that finished last gets the first pick, and the champion gets the last pick.
Q2: Can I use a random draft selection for my league?
A2: Yes, absolutely! A random draft selection, often done via a lottery or a draft order generator, is a fair and popular method, especially for new leagues or leagues seeking a fresh start.
Q3: How does a snake draft order work?
A3: In a snake draft, the draft order reverses after each round. For example, if the order in Round 1 is 1-12, the order in Round 2 will be 12-1. This pattern continues, with the order flipping back and forth for subsequent rounds.
Q4: What if my league uses an auction draft? How is the order determined?
A4: For auction drafts, the “order” refers to the nomination order. This is typically determined by a random lottery or a draft order generator, as it dictates who gets to nominate the first player for auction.
Q5: How can I ensure my league’s draft order is fair?
A5: Fairness is achieved by using a method that is transparent, agreed upon by all league members, and applied consistently. Methods like random lotteries or reverse standings minimize bias. Clearly communicating the chosen method and its implementation is crucial.
Q6: What if there are ties in the standings for draft order?
A6: Most leagues have pre-defined tie-breaking rules. Common tie-breakers include head-to-head records between tied teams, total points scored, or simply a coin flip or random draw. It’s essential to establish these tie-breaking rules before the season starts.
Q7: Are there any “custom draft rules” I can implement for draft order?
A7: Yes, leagues can get creative. Some might tie draft order to the previous year’s playoff outcomes, use a tiered randomization, or even incorporate elements from real-life sports to determine the order. Just ensure all custom rules are clearly communicated and agreed upon by everyone.
Q8: Where can I find a draft order generator?
A8: Many popular fantasy sports platforms (like ESPN, Yahoo, Sleeper) have built-in draft order generators. You can also find numerous independent websites that offer free draft order generator tools online.
Q9: How much does draft preparation matter for draft order?
A9: While draft preparation is vital for team building, the determination of the draft order is about establishing fairness and setting the stage. Ensuring the order method is understood and agreed upon before draft preparation begins is the key to a smooth start.
Q10: What is the general consensus on the best draft order method?
A10: There isn’t a single “best” method, as it depends on league preference. However, reverse standings and random lotteries are generally considered the fairest and most widely accepted. The goal is to find a method that promotes competition and enjoyment for all participants.
By carefully considering these methods and engaging your league in the decision-making process, you can establish a draft order that sets the stage for a competitive, enjoyable, and memorable fantasy football season.